Dunkirk Disaster Or Triumph Essay
The Battle of Dunkirk Essay examples
905 Words4 Pages
The Battle of Dunkirk
In my opinion the battle of Dunkirk can be seen as both a deliverance and disaster. It can be seen as a deliverance by the fact that the British and French survived which is a great feat on it's own, because seeing what predicament the British and French were in, it was likely they were going to lose. They turned the tables and 338,000 men were saved. On the other hand, it can be seen as a disaster because out of the 338,000 men saved 139,997 were French, so for British morale that wasn't very good. Also even Churchill said, "Wars are not won by evacuation". Some would say that Britain still lived to fight another day that is also an important point. I will try to come to a…show more content…
He says that the soldiers have become "a body of seasoned veterans".This source really tells us a lot about the use of propaganda spread out. The question is, isn't a veteran someone who has experienced war. He speaks of how their spirits are strong and that's their "vital" weapon so they will refuse defeat, and that's their "guarantee to victory". You can see he is complementing his side too much, it seems too shallow. This is insufficient on telling us on what the battle was like, because it is a piece of propaganda.
We get a mixed picture from sources D, E and F. This is because analyzing these sources it seems that the battle was a deliverance and disaster. Source D's a painting showing the soldiers being rescued, it shows their stairing for survival. The artist who painted this was sent to give the British some hope. However this painting is contemporary, meaning that it is at that time. Now, source E shows the soldiers on the beach waiting to be evacuated. The problem with this source is that it is a still life picture meaning, it's just one second of someone's life.From all we know a German heinikel could have dropped a bomb any time killing the soldiers just after this photo was taken. Source F shows the soldiers warding off German fighter planes. This to is a very good photo on propaganda to boost British
Was Dunkirk a Triumph or a Disaster? Why? Essay
1138 WordsJun 17th, 20115 Pages
Dunkirk battle could be called a failure or success depending on the viewpoint. From 27th May to 4th June the British Expeditionary Force with the remainder of the French and Belgian armies were attacked from behind by the Germans while waiting for a ‘ferry service’ back to Britain.
After their defeat at Calais, in May 1940, the British army were ordered to retreat from the area and get to the coastal area of Dunkirk no matter what. There they would be rescued by the British naval forces. However, the Brits were left waiting until the 27th of May. Whilst the German Luftwaffe was bombing them from above and the land army was shelling them from below, the Allied troops waited and took the best cover possible. All they could do was wait.…show more content…
This battle was also militarily a failure. The British and French armies suffered their worst military defeat since World War One. They were soundly decimated by the German military (via their Blitzkrieg tactics) in Calais, which meant a surrender of the easy Allied escape route. It was literally an evacuation due to the overall loss of the war so far. Owing to this loss, Dunkirk can be considered a failure.
To summarize, Dunkirk can be considered a spectacular failure on the part of the Allies, rather than a victory.
Conversely, Dunkirk can be considered a success in a number of ways.
The initial rescue target for the British navy was set at around 30,000. With the huge amount of large battleships in use by the navy, not many soldiers were expected to be rescued. However, with the input of the many small cruisers and privately-owned vessels, the number exceeded the original target by over twelve times. 139,000 French were rescued, along with 220,000 of the British Expeditionary Force. The rest were mainly comprised of Belgians, Polish Soldiers and Czechs. This saved over 50% of the BEF from annihilation, which, in the long term, enabled the Allies to win the war. They formed a small rèsistance along with the other Allies to fight the Germans. Even though over 100,000 losses were suffered by the Allied troops,